Likely to be Sydney W Smith. Melbourne Mansions Data Base record 2284 identifies property as being 2 doors from Eden Terrace which puts it at 'Kara' at 28 Dalgety St. Not 32. General building description seems to be closer to Kara than 32 Dalgety Street.  Records at SLV of  BEMJ need to be checked Journal is part of collection 1888-1907 pg 412. Journal number SLTF 690.5.B868